What is the Orthodox Christian view on the atonement and is Penal Substitutionary Atonement Orthodox?

The patristic and biblical quotes in this collection reveal what Orthodox Christians actually teach about the atonement, debunking prevailing myths. The quotes show multiple biblical and patristic perspectives: Christ as 'ransom for all' (1 Tim 2:6), 'triumphing over' principalities and powers (Col 2:15), and the 'sweet exchange' where 'the iniquity of many should be concealed in One Righteous Man, and the righteousness of One should justify many that are iniquitous' (St. Athanasius). Rather than modern theories, the Church Fathers emphasize Christ taking 'upon Himself our sins' as 'a ransom for us, holy for lawless, guileless for evil, just for the unjust' (St. Athanasius). These truthful quotes help debunk misconceptions about what the Orthodox Church has historically taught about the atonement.

The quotes in this collection help debunk myths by showing the actual range of patristic and biblical teaching on atonement. Some emphasize Christ bearing our sins ('he made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin' - 2 Cor 5:21), others focus on propitiation ('he is propitiation for our sins' - 1 John 2:2), while others highlight Christ as a ransom or victory over death. By presenting both substitutionary language and themes of divine wrath directly from the sources, this collection helps readers distinguish between prevailing myths and what the Church Fathers actually teach.

CAESARIUS OF ARLES on the Atonement

Christ's death profited man, for by taking death upon Himself Christ paid what Adam owed to God. Truly He became a sacrifice for the sin of men and their progeny, as blessed Paul declares: Christ loved us and delivered himself up for us an offering and a sacrifice to God to ascend in fragrant odor (Eph. 5:2). Original sin could not have easily been forgiven, if a victim had not been offered for it, if that sacred blood of propitiation had not been shed. Even then the words in Exodus were not vainly said of our Lord: I shall see the blood, and shall protect you (Ex. 12:13). That figure of the lamb represented this Passion of Christ our Lord. Blood is given for blood, death for death, a victim for sin, and thus the Devil lost what he held.

CAESARIUS OF ARLES

St. Caesarius of Arles (+542), Sermon 9

Sixth Century